Morse Code with Korby Lenker
Morse Code Podcast with Korby Lenker
James McMurtry: The Beast in All of Us | MCP #402
0:00
-59:52

James McMurtry: The Beast in All of Us | MCP #402

Ken Kesey’s sketch, his father’s typewriter, and my reluctant political debut

There’s a pencil sketch on the cover of James McMurtry’s latest record ‘The Black Dog and the Wandering Boy’. He found it going through his father’s things after Larry [McMurtry, who wrote Lonesome Dove] died, and he didn’t know who drew it. His mother said it wasn’t hers. His stepmother, Faye, said it looked like Ken’s. Kesey and Larry had been in the same writing class at Stanford, and the Merry Pranksters came by the house twice when James was a kid. He remembers the second time.

With a childhood like that, you’d expect a son to grow up writing about himself. James does the opposite. He hears a couple of lines with a melody, and if they keep him up at night he works backwards. He asks: who would say this? What’s their story?

“I can’t write straight autobiography,” he told me. “Nobody wants to listen to it.” Watch the full conversation.

Then he and BettySoo played “Sons of the Second Sons,” a song about the European second sons who couldn’t inherit and came here to make a living, and what their descendants are still carrying. Here’s the performance. My daughter contributed a few pitchy background vocals.

If you’re still reading this, I’ll reward your patience with a little candor: this was the hardest interview I’ve ever done. James often gave one-line answers to questions that had a long setup, and usually there was a correction in that answer. I got the sense early on that he didn’t like me. At several points in the conversation, I wonde

red why he had agreed to the interview in the first place. He clearly didn’t want to be there. Suddenly, the conversation broke wide open. James does not want to talk about songwriting or the creative process. What really excites him? Politics.

Anyone who has listened to this podcast knows that I don’t really live there nor am I interested very much in the subject, but I go where the guest is most alive, so off we went.

James thinks music is politics. Every night he tells a room full of strangers that he carries a passport in case he wants to leave the country, and BettySoo carries a passport and a birth certificate in case she wants to stay. I kept thinking of my interracial marriage (to be clear James and BettySoo are just musical partners). I have never worried that my wife would be deported because she’s not white. After the interview I asked Randa if she questioned her security as a U.S. citizen. She said she had never once thought about it, much less traveled with a birth certificate. You could make an argument that we’re oblivious, and I suppose I could make an argument that you find what you look for. James is looking for villains. I’m looking for friends. I came into the conversation wanting the people on the other side - Trump voters, say - to stay reachable. He told me there’s not going to be a kumbaya moment. In his view there’s a beast in all of us that has to be contained, and the only way to do that is to make cruelty bad for business.

Near the end of the interview I observed aloud that a lot of the characters in his songs probably voted for the guy he can’t stand. He didn’t argue. He’s spent more than thirty years inside the heads of people he disagrees with, giving them their own words, and maybe that empathy - absent in his personal politics - is what drives the music. Maybe the songs are where the reaching happens. Songs do that after all.

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?